Add your business ↗

Best Pizza in Chico? Yelp’s Top 10 Results—Yes or Hell No?

Who makes the best pizza in Chico? Yelp’s search results give us ten contenders. FindChico wants your verdict: did they get it right—YES or HELL NO?

Freshly baked pizza with melted cheese and toppings
Illustrative pizza photograph by Ivan Torres / Unsplash; not a photograph from one of the restaurants listed.

Ask ten Chico residents for their favorite pizza and you may get ten different answers. Some want a thin, foldable slice. Others care most about the sauce, generous toppings or feeding the family. The best choice for a quick lunch might be different from your pick for a night out.

We have connected every restaurant below to a FindChico review form. Use the review link beside its name to share your own experience and help another local choose their next pizza stop.

About the list: Order, star ratings and review counts come from the first ten numbered listings in Yelp screenshots supplied on October 20, 2026. They are a historical snapshot, not live ratings or a FindChico taste-test ranking. Search position is not the same as ranking by stars, and results can change.

Chico pizza restaurants: compare the results and leave a review

Restaurant Yelp snapshot
October 20, 2026
Your experience
1. Bodega Pizza 4.4 stars · 85 reviews Review on FindChico →
2. Westside Pizza 4.8 stars · 29 reviews Review on FindChico →
3. JT’s Oven 4.3 stars · 160 reviews Review on FindChico →
4. Celestino’s New York Pizza 4.2 stars · 420 reviews Review on FindChico →
5. Farm Star Pizza 4.2 stars · 351 reviews Review on FindChico →
6. Tio’s Pizza 3.3 stars · 32 reviews Review on FindChico →
7. Celestino’s Pizza & Pasta 2.9 stars · 185 reviews Review on FindChico →
8. Woodstock’s Pizza Chico 3.8 stars · 424 reviews Review on FindChico →
9. Mountain Mike’s Pizza 3.2 stars · 118 reviews Review on FindChico →
10. Monstros Pizza 4.5 stars · 109 reviews Review on FindChico →

1. Bodega Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.4 stars | 85 reviews

Bodega starts the original lineup in first place. Downtown Chico’s business association lists it as Bodega Slice Shop, a Main Street spot serving New York-style slices and whole pies. If you judge pizza by the slice, this is one to explore. Does it deserve the top spot? Tell other readers what you ordered and how it stacked up.

Location: 148 Main Street.

Browse restaurant information and menu

2. Westside Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.8 stars | 29 reviews

Westside had the highest star rating among these ten results, yet appeared second. It also had the smallest review count, so that score represents a different amount of feedback than the hundreds of reviews behind some other names. Its official Chico page lists takeout and delivery from Walnut Street. Is Westside your first choice for pizza night?

Location: 206 Walnut Street, Suite A.

Browse restaurant information and menu

3. JT’s Oven

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.3 stars | 160 reviews

JT’s Oven puts pizza, subs and wings on the menu at its East Avenue location. It landed third in the supplied results, making it another contender in a conversation that often comes down to crust, toppings and value. If this is your regular stop, share your go-to order and what keeps you coming back.

Location: 1380 East Avenue, Suite 120.

Browse restaurant information and menu

4. Celestino’s New York Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.2 stars | 420 reviews

This Celestino’s listing had one of the largest review counts in the group. Fourth place may feel fair to some Chico pizza fans and far too low to others. Keep it separate from the East Avenue Pizza & Pasta entry below when comparing ratings or writing a review. Name the location you visited so your feedback helps the next diner.

5. Farm Star Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.2 stars | 351 reviews

Farm Star rounds out the first five. Its Esplanade restaurant describes a focus on scratch-made food, using local and organic ingredients when available. For diners who care as much about what goes on a pizza as the crust underneath it, that offers a reason to browse the menu. Should Farm Star be in your top three?

Location: 2359 Esplanade.

Browse restaurant information and menu

6. Tio’s Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 3.3 stars | 32 reviews

Tio’s appeared sixth in the original search. Its featured customer excerpt emphasized games for children and a family-friendly atmosphere, reminding us that a pizza outing can be about more than the pie. If you have visited, explain what worked for your group—and whether the food, service and overall experience would bring you back.

7. Celestino’s Pizza & Pasta

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 2.9 stars | 185 reviews

The East Avenue Pizza & Pasta restaurant is a separate entry from Celestino’s New York Pizza above. Its snapshot rating was the lowest in this group, but a historical average cannot describe every visit. Browse its current menu and contribute a specific, firsthand review if you have eaten here. What did you order, and did the experience meet your expectations?

Location: 1354 East Avenue, Suite V.

Browse restaurant information and menu

8. Woodstock’s Pizza Chico

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 3.8 stars | 424 reviews

Woodstock’s had the largest review count in this ten-result snapshot. At eighth place, it is likely to spark a debate among diners who make it part of a downtown outing. Is your choice driven by the pizza, the atmosphere or the people you go with? A useful review tells readers which parts of the experience earned your rating.

Location: 240 Main Street, Suite 100.

Browse restaurant information and menu

9. Mountain Mike’s Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 3.2 stars | 118 reviews

Mountain Mike’s appeared ninth in the supplied results. For readers ready to share a local experience, the review link here goes specifically to the Chico restaurant on Mangrove Avenue, which its official website lists for dine-in, carryout and delivery. Review that location only if it is the one you visited; the original screenshot rating should not be treated as a rating for every branch.

Location: 1722 Mangrove Avenue — review link is for this location.

Browse restaurant information and menu

10. Monstros Pizza

Review on FindChico →

Yelp snapshot: 4.5 stars | 109 reviews

Monstros makes the clearest argument against reading search position as a best-to-worst ranking. It appeared tenth while holding the second-highest star rating in the group. Its West Sacramento Avenue location is listed in local restaurant directories; confirm current hours and ordering arrangements before making a trip. Does Monstros belong much higher on your personal list?

Location: 628 W Sacramento Avenue.

Browse restaurant information

Did Yelp get Chico’s best pizza right?

Do we agree with treating this search order as a definitive best-to-worst ranking? Hell no.

The numbers explain why. Westside had the highest rating but appeared second. Monstros had the second-highest rating but appeared tenth. Review counts ranged from 29 to 424. Those are useful differences to consider, but none proves which pizza you will enjoy most.

Our take: this is a starting point for exploring Chico pizza, not a final verdict. Recent, detailed reviews can explain things a star average cannot—how a crust held up on the drive home, whether an order was ready when promised, or which toppings you would order again.

Chico, make your case: yes or hell no?

Click Review on FindChico beside a restaurant you have visited. Tell us what you ordered, roughly when you went and why you would—or would not—return. Include the location, especially when a business has more than one. Positive and critical reviews are both welcome; keep them respectful and based on your own experience. Reviews are moderated before publication.

Check current hours, menus and prices directly before visiting. If your favorite is missing from these ten results, share your local recommendation. You can also explore the FindChico pizza directory or compare our Chinese restaurants in Chico guide.

Sources and editorial note: Yelp’s pizza search for Chico, as shown in the supplied October 20 screenshots; restaurant websites linked above; and Downtown Chico’s Bodega Slice Shop profile. This article does not claim firsthand dining experience. Yelp ratings are separate from customer reviews submitted to FindChico.

undefined